updated 9/21/2011 9:59:28 AM ET 2011-09-21T13:59:28

Airline trade groups are fighting President Barack Obama's plan to raise fees on airlines and passengers to pay for aviation security and air-traffic control.

  1. Don't miss these Travel stories
    1. Lords of the gourd compete for Punkin Chunkin honors

      With teams using more than 100 unique apparatuses to launch globular projectiles a half-mile or more, the 27th annual World Championship Punkin Chunkin event is our pick as November’s Weird Festival of the Month.

    2. Airports, airlines work hard to return your lost items
    3. Expert: Tourist hordes threaten Sistine Chapel's art
    4. MGM Grand wants Las Vegas guests to Stay Well
    5. Report: Airlines collecting $36.1B in fees this year

The airlines say security is a national-defense function and they pay an unfair share. The administration argues that those who use the air-travel system — airlines and passengers — should pay for it.

The aviation fees are part of Obama's deficit-cutting plan that was released Tuesday. The plan would:

— raise the passenger security fee — now $5 to $10 per round trip — to $15 by 2017 and give the Homeland Security Department the power to push it higher.

— impose a surcharge of $100 per flight to help pay for air traffic control.

The administration portrayed the $100 surcharge as a tax on corporate jets, whose owners pay fuel taxes but not ticket taxes and other fees already paid by airlines and their passengers. However the surcharge would also apply to regular airline flights — providing most of the $11 billion that the surcharge would raise over 10 years.

The Air Transport Association, which represents large airlines, said it's unfair for airlines and passengers to pay for security against terror attacks that target the U.S. and not the airlines themselves. The trade group says a typical $300 round-trip ticket already includes $60 in taxes and fees.

The Regional Airline Association, a group of smaller carriers, said the fees could lead to a loss of flights to smaller cities. The group's president, Roger Cohen, said the $100 surcharge would cost more than regional airlines earned last year, threatening service to smaller cities.

The groups also complained that some of the money raised from airlines and passengers would be used to pay down the federal budget deficit and not to improve the air-travel system.

The administration estimated that boosting passenger security fees will raise $24.9 billion over 10 years. It proposed to spend $15 billion of that to reduce federal debt.

The airline groups argue that raising taxes will hurt demand for travel.

"The airline industry is not a cash cow," said Steve Lott, a spokesman for the Air Transport Association. "During the best of times, the airlines have razor-thin profit margins."

Lott said if taxes are raised, airlines will have to increase fares or cut service.

Robert Mann, an aviation consultant in Port Washington, N.Y., said the airlines undercut their own case against taxes this summer, when Congress let some federal aviation taxes expire briefly. Rather than passing the tax savings to consumers, most airlines kept the money by raising fares an equal amount.

"It's simply Economics 101 that taxes, fees or any higher out-of-pocket costs ... depress demand, especially price-seeking leisure demand," Mann said, "but you could never tell it by the recent behavior" of most airlines.

The airlines have also boosted their own fees on passengers for checking baggage and changing reservations. The largest U.S. airlines collected $1.4 billion from those fees in the first three months of this year, up 4.5 percent from a year earlier, according to government figures.

Story: A few strategies to avoid baggage fees

The nation's largest airlines earned an operating profit of $5.9 billion last year but had a loss of $285 million, or 1.1 percent, in the first quarter of 2011, the Transportation Department said.

The prospects for the aviation fees are uncertain. Obama's deficit plan is given little chance of passing Congress, but parts of it could resurface in a plan to be written this fall by a so-called supercommittee of Congress charged with cutting government spending. And that has the airline industry worried.

Copyright 2011 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Video: Airlines nickel-and-dime fliers with fees

  1. Closed captioning of: Airlines nickel-and-dime fliers with fees

    >>> you've purchased a plane ticket recently you know that those extra fees are really starting to add up. the transportation department is telling airlines they need to fully disclose all of their fees online and this morning we're getting an eye-opening look at just what we're paying for. nbc's tom costello is in seattle with details on this. hi, tom.

    >> reporter: hi, matt, good morning to you. the airlines call this ala-carte pricing, you pay for the extras, the leg room, the luggage. the airlines tell us this is what the passengers want. we haven't found any passengers or travelers who have said that to us. if you feel like you're getting nickelled and dimed every time you fly it turns out it's a lot more than pocket change .

    >> it is shocking. you show up and you go to check in and all of the sudden there's a $25 or $50 or $75 fee.

    >> reporter: it's been adding up for years, fees for buying your ticket over the phone for online, ticket change fees, baggage fees, fees for extra ledge room, aisle seats, no the to mention a boxed lunch.

    >> you don't know how much it costs until you're done paying the fees.

    >> reporter: " usa today " crunched the numbers, the first checked bag can cost as much as $43 but an overweight international bag can run you up to $400 on continental and you ni united $450 on american, $250 changing a ticket and spirit airlines charges $30 to $40 for carry-on bags.

    >> travelers are feeling a huge level of rage. they're wary. they're angry. they're strained in their personal lives and certainly in their finances.

    >> reporter: after losing $65 billion over the last ten years, the airlines insist those extra fees are the only way they can turn a profit.

    >> airlines need to be profitable. without being sustainably profitable they can't provide jobs, they can't provide service to the destinations the customers want to fly to.

    >> reporter: still to a lot of passengers it feels like gouging.

    >> makes me feel like traveling has gotten to be so expensive it's almost prohibitive.

    >> reporter: unfortunately the reality is, if you plan to fly there's no escaping the squeeze. now the airlines insist that if you look at air fares today, base fares and factor in inflation and compare it to ten years ago it's cheaper to fly today than it was ten years ago but of course ten years ago we didn't have to pay for all the extras. one way to avoid paying more is to fly more, because more frequent fliers get those extra fees waived. i flew here to seattle late yesterday and my bag flew for free. back to you, matt.

    >> tom costello, good advice as always. thank you very much.


Discussion comments


Most active discussions

  1. votes comments
  2. votes comments
  3. votes comments
  4. votes comments