You know you need to know your credit score, but how do you get it without getting shafted?
Credit scores serve as the report card for consumer adulthood in America. But bad grades can cost you a lot more than embarrassment -- they lead to higher interest rates and fewer opportunities. In one typical scenario offered up by MyFico.com, a 120-point difference in credit score could cost a home buyer with a $300,000 loan about $300 extra every month in mortgage interest, or more than $100,000 in additional interest during the life of the loan. So knowing your credit score is of paramount importance.
You might have heard that Americans will enjoy increased access to their credit scores this year thanks to the massive financial reform bill passed by Congress last year. That’s true, but scores are still a long way from being truly free. The Fair Access to Credit Scores Act forces lenders to divulge credit score information to consumers, but only after something bad has happened, such as a rejected application. That’s a little like getting your cholesterol numbers from the doctor after you suffer a heart attack.
It’s important to know your score before you apply for a car loan or a home loan, but for the foreseeable future, you’ll have to pay for it. Here are five common Red Tape Traps you face getting your credit score, along with information on the right way to get it.
1) Many Web sites and TV ads say they offer your score for free. None of them are telling the truth. There’s no way to get it for free. With only slight variation, most free score Web sites require users to sign up for credit monitoring services that can cost $150 or more annually. Sure, there are free trial periods, but many consumers report trouble canceling the trial before their credit cards are charged and getting refunds.
2) Even when you do sign up with a “free” score service, the scores you receive are usually not the “real” credit score used by lenders, but an approximation based on a separate formula. These imitation scores can vary by 100 points from the FICO score used by about roughly 8 out of 10 lenders. That means their real value is suspect.
3) You can buy your “real” FICO score from MyFico.com. But it costs $19.95 for a one-time peek. And you’ll have to hunt around for the chance to buy it. The MyFico folks are playing the same game everyone else does, teasing you on their home page with a big link that says “Free Instant Online Access” and entices you to fill out a bunch of forms. Once you do, you are hit with a $14.95 credit monitoring subscription. How any company can justify a home page link that reads “Free Instant Online Access” link, but connects to a final page button that reads “Make Purchase Now,” is beyond me. Here’s the correct link for a one-time purchase. If you have any doubts at all about your credit health, you should buy your score a couple of months before making a major lending decision.
4) The term FICO score is a bit misleading. Consumers usually have three FICO scores, one for each credit bureau. Each bureau generates a score based on the FICO formula created by the Fair Issac company in the 1960s.Because the information in your three credit reports can vary, the three FICO scores can vary. You must pay $19.95 for each score, but in many cases -- if your three reports contain similar information -- purchasing one of the scores is good enough, says scoring expert John Ulzheimer, president of Consumer Education for SmartCredit.com. Consumers in the South should opt for an Equifax score; all other consumers should purchase from Trans Union, based on the companies’ geographic market dominance, Ulzheimer said.
For good measure, here’s an even more confusing (and relatively recent) development -- MyFico.com users can only obtain two of their three scores, the FICO scores generated using Trans Union and Equifax data. Experian no longer allows the MyFico folks to sell their score, meaning there is no way for consumers to obtain this information prior to a purchase. Two out of three will have to do. Remember, other services that sell credit scores can only approximate the FICO formula and score. And one final bit of confusion: while most lenders rely on these FICO-based scores, many lenders have their own, proprietary scores. There’s no way to obtain them pre-purchase, either.
There are tools which allow you to estimate your score for free, however. Ulzheimer says consumers can create a “poor man’s versions” of their credit score by obtaining their credit reports, then plugging the data into one of the tools offered by MyFico.com or Bankrate.com. The score ranges churned out by the tools are “pretty accurate,” he said.
The Fair Isaac folks even offer an iPhone app which offers a score estimating tool. You can read more about it at this link.
5) Don’t confuse your credit score with your credit report. Both are important but are used very differently. The best truly free way to deal with a potentially bad score before a purchase is to deal with the underlying issues that cause it. Obtain a copy of your credit report at the only authorized source: http://AnnualCreditReport.com . Then, work to clean up the report one black mark at a time by disputing inaccuracies and paying off past-due balances. Here's an FTC tip sheet on the dispute process.
What’s a good credit score? That’s hard to answer: http://www.credit.com/blog/2010/04/whats-a-good-credit-score-these-days/
Will you ever get a free score? http://www.credit.com/news/experts/2010-09-10/the-man-behind-the-fair-access-to-credit-scores-act.html
Herb Weisbaum -- Free Credit Scores (for some): http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/41159095/ns/business-retail/
Liz Weston -- Free scores for all? Not so fast
U.S. government consumer info: http://www.pueblo.gsa.gov/cic_text/money/creditscores/your.htm
Credit score basics from Fair Isaac: http://scoreinfo.org/
“Five Red Tape Traps” is an occasional series which will focus on answering the most important questions consumer face in the 21st Century economy. What traps have you found obtaining your credit score? What other basic personal finance questions do you have? Respond below.
First published February 23 2011, 7:00 AM