IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.

Lufthansa pays $300 million for JetBlue stake

Germany's biggest airline, Deutsche Lufthansa AG, said Thursday it is paying $300 million for a 19 percent stake in JetBlue Airways Corp.
/ Source: The Associated Press

Germany's biggest airline, Deutsche Lufthansa AG, said Thursday it is paying $300 million for a 19 percent stake in JetBlue Airways Corp., whose stock has lost about two thirds of its value since an operational meltdown last Valentine's Day.

The move, which could be a precursor to an eventual takeover if U.S. laws are changed, comes as the euro has risen significantly against the dollar, making U.S. companies seem like bargains for European buyers.

JetBlue CEO Dave Barger, who replaced founder David Neeleman this year, said the agreement "reaffirms our belief in JetBlue's disciplined growth plan and will also improve our balance sheet and give us greater financial flexibility as we move into 2008."

JetBlue shares rose 90 cents, or 14.4 percent, to $7.15 Thursday. But that still leaves them about 50 percent below they were in February when an ice storm hit New York, leading to a series of snafus that left passengers stuck in planes on taxiways for hours and ground much of its fleet for days.

The Forest-Hills, New York-based airline, which began service in 2000 as a low-cost carrier, promised to beef up its staffing and take other steps to better deal with weather and other disruptions. But those added costs came just as fuel expenses were soaring and the airline posted a first-quarter loss and tepid earnings since then. It also scaled back its expansion plans.

The cash infusion will come in handy for JetBlue, which has $433 million in current debt payable that it otherwise would have been "hard-pressed to fund from cash flow from operations or cash on hand," according to a note from William Greene, an analyst at Morgan Stanley & Co.

In a statement, Lufthansa said it would acquire about 42 million newly issued shares from the JetBlue for $7.27 per share, a 16 percent premium over Wednesday's closing price.

A Lufthansa nominee will be appointed to JetBlue's board of directors once the deal is concluded. JetBlue said the deal does not require approval from its shareholders.

The deal provides for an "operation cooperation," but the companies said no specific areas of integration of flight schedules or systems have been identified.

"This investment presents Lufthansa with a compelling opportunity to invest in the U.S. point-to-point carrier market as the industry continues to evolve," said Lufthansa Chief Executive Wolfgang Mayrhuber.

In a conference call with investors and analysts, Barger said the transaction was purely financial, and that no code-sharing arrangements have been discussed.

If the airlines do agree to share codes, or let passengers book tickets that make it easier to move seamlessly from one airline to another, Lufthansa will benefit more than JetBlue from the deal, said Ray Neidl, an analyst at Calyon Securities in New York, because it will give the German carrier access to more passengers for its trans-Atlantic flights from JetBlue's hub at New York's John F. Kennedy International Airport.

But the deal left some analysts scratching their heads.

"It's not clear to us what Lufthansa gains from such a transaction," Greene said. "It may be that Lufthansa wishes to ensure access to JFK and by taking a stake in JetBlue, Lufthansa ensures that it will have slots if the FAA reimposes (flight caps) at JFK."

JetBlue sells a single class of seat, whereas Lufthansa sells three classes, noted Bob Mann, an airline consultant in Port Washington, New York. Lufthansa may have a hard time convincing its first-class customers to jump from their large seats to JetBlue's economy-class seats, regardless of JetBlue perks like free DirecTV, Mann said.

"I am struggling with why this (makes sense)," Mann said.

Lufthansa already has code-sharing agreements with UAL Corp.'s United Airlines and US Airways, Mann noted. JetBlue's reservation system, meanwhile, doesn't accommodate code-sharing, he said.

But these problems could be easily fixed, Neidl argued.

A JetBlue stake also puts Lufthansa in the driver's seat for any potential longer-term takeover of JetBlue. Lufthansa is barred from such a takeover under current laws restricting foreign ownership of domestic airlines to 25 percent, but lifting that cap was a key demand of European negotiators during talks earlier this year on an "Open Skies" deal, which was reached in March.

The Bush administration proposed lifting the cap, but backed down in the face of opposition from U.S. airlines and labor unions, who feared its impact on jobs. Several members of Congress also opposed the proposal.

Barger said the companies did not discuss the possibility of an acquisition in the event the ownership restrictions were lifted.

"There was never really any dialogue about 'what if,' " said Barger, who added that the deal doesn't change JetBlue's strategy of avoiding takeovers and growing alone.

The Open Skies agreement, which is scheduled to take effect March 30, 2008, will allow airlines to fly from anywhere in Europe to the United States and vice versa. Currently, for example, London's Heathrow airport only grants access to four U.S. airlines.

But the agreement doesn't allow European Union airlines to fly between U.S. cities, giving a carrier such as Lufthansa an incentive to hook up with a U.S. airline.

Lufthansa, whose last acquisition was the airline Swiss, recently decided not to bid on Italian airline Alitalia SpA. Mayrhuber has said Lufthansa is looking for acquisition candidates.