IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.

List worries both sides of immigration debate

Advocates of tougher immigration enforcement condemned a list of alleged illegal immigrants to Utah state agencies and news organizations.
/ Source: and NBC News

SALT LAKE CITY — Advocates of tougher immigration enforcement joined civil rights activists in condemning circulation this week of a list of alleged illegal immigrants to Utah state agencies and news organizations, saying it sent the wrong message to violate privacy laws in seeking to enforce immigration laws. The 30-page document included addresses, phone numbers and birthdates for about 1,300 people it said were in the country illegally. Some of the names — almost all of which were of Latino origin — also were accompanied by Social Security numbers and medical information, such as “baby due 4/4/10.”

A cover letter demanded that the people on the list be “deported immediately” with a call to “DO YOUR JOB AND STOP MAKING EXCUSES! WE DEMAND ACTION.” It identified the senders as Concerned Citizens of the United States, a previously unknown group.

The cover letter said the list had been sent to U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement on April 4. ICE confirmed Tuesday that it received the list but said that “as a matter of policy” it could not confirm or deny whether it was taking any action.

Immigration and civil rights experts said Wednesday it was not immediately possible to verify whether the information in the list was accurate, but they said it appeared to have been derived from state records. “That kind of information is collected by government, for government purposes, and it’s supposed to be protected by government,” said Brian Barnard, managing attorney of the nonprofit Utah Civil Rights & Liberties Foundation. “If it was illegally accessed to create that list, that’s a crime, and it’s something that government should be concerned about.”

Gov. Gary Herbert ordered an investigation to determine whether state resources were illegally used to generate the list.

Bernard’s concern was shared by Rep. Steven Sandstrom, R-Orem, who is drafting a Utah version of the controversial law in Arizona that cracks down on illegal immigration.

“I think it’s a wrong approach,” Sandstrom said. “It sends the wrong message, and it doesn’t follow the rule of law with the bill that I’m writing.”

Ronald W. Mortensen, a vocal proponent of cracking down on illegal immigrants, agreed, saying circulation of the list “wasn’t an appropriate action.”

“It’s never right to release documents,” said Mortensen, a co-founder of the Utah Coalition on Illegal Immigration, which denied having had anything to do with the list.

‘I’m angry, because I’m legal here’
Circulation of the list created alarm among immigrant communities in Utah.

Tony Yapias, director of the nonprofit group Proyecto Latino de Utah, said he had taken calls from many frightened people.

Yapias, former director the Utah Office of Hispanic Affairs, said he told a caller: “Look, I have your name, your address — I have all your information.”

“She just could not believe it,” he said. “You can’t do that to people.”

One woman, who is not being identified by name to protect her, told NBC station KSL-TV of Salt Lake City that she was on the list inaccurately.

“I have my papers!” the woman said, saying she had had her green card for more than a decade and was scheduled to become a U.S. citizen next month.

“I’m angry, because I’m legal here,” she said. “I’m going to be a citizen in August — I have the ceremony in August.”

Marina Baginsky Lowe, a lawyer with the American Civil Liberties Union of Utah, called the list “distressing,” describing it as “vigilante action.”

“Are we now going to be living in a place where we have to worry about our neighbors spying on us, taking down our private information and delivering it to law enforcement under the guise of taking the law into their own hands?” she asked.

Minuteman group denies involvement
Suspicion initially surfaced that the Utah Minuteman Project, a group that says it works “to secure our home land from those who illegally cross our borders,” was behind the list. But Eli Cawley, the group’s co-chairman, told KSL that his group was not involved.

He said he supported the list, but only as long as the information was accurate and was obtained legally.

“If you had a legitimate list that didn’t unnecessarily or negligently point out citizens and legal residents, then I think that would serve the greater interest,” Cawley said, adding that protecting legal Utah residents outweighed the privacy of illegal immigrants.