IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.

Experts pinpoint fall zone for failed Russian probe

Space junk experts have confirmed when and where the wayward Russian Mars probe Phobos-Grunt re-entered the atmosphere and crashed back to Earth.
This artist's concept shows fuel from Russia's failed Mars probe Phobos-Grunt burning from a ruptured fuel tank as the spacecraft re-enters the atmosphere.
This artist's concept shows fuel from Russia's failed Mars probe Phobos-Grunt burning from a ruptured fuel tank as the spacecraft re-enters the atmosphere.Michael Carroll
/ Source:

Space junk experts have confirmed when and where the wayward Russian Mars probe Phobos-Grunt re-entered the atmosphere and crashed back to Earth.

The doomed Phobos-Grunt spacecraft fell from space on Jan. 15, and crashed near the South American coastline — with any debris probably falling into ocean waters, according to a European Space Agency update released Wednesday.

"Probably" can also mean that some free-falling fragments might have reached land. However, there have been no confirmed reports of debris reaching land.

"While this was an uncontrolled re-entry, the location of the potential impact area was largely over ocean, with a correspondingly low probability of any detrimental effects," Heiner Klinkrad, head of ESA’s Space Debris Office in Darmstadt, Germany, said in a statement.

Klinkrad told that the associated re-entry location of Phobos-Grunt "is in the vicinity of the South American coastline."

When asked about the delayed publishing of the Phobos-Grunt re-entry data, which came more than a week after the spacecraft actually fell, Klinkrad said, "I cannot comment."

[In a follow-up interview with, Klinkrad acknowledged that the delay in publication was "not the norm," and suggested that future re-entry estimates should typically come more quickly.]

An ocean grave for Phobos-Grunt
Scientists make spacecraft re-entry predictions based on the assumption that a spacecraft remains intact and reaches an altitude of 6.2 miles (10 kilometers) above Earth's surface. Most of the spacecraft debris would typically impact Earth prior to that location, since most debris is "lighter" — that is, they have a greater area-to-mass ratio than the spacecraft as a whole.

Following Phobos-Grunt's fall from space, the U.S. Strategic Command confirmed a re-entry time of 12:46 p.m. ET as the spacecraft was flying about nearly 50 miles (80 kilometers) above the South American coast at a location of 46 degrees south and 87 degrees west.

"This corresponds to a pass at 10 km altitude about seven minutes later — very close to ESA's prediction," according to the ESA update.

That seven-minute time delay is presumed to be roughly how long it took for Phobos-Grunt to fall from a 50-mile (80-kilometer) altitude to an altitude of 6.2 miles (10 kilometers).

Marooned Mars probe
Phobos-Grunt tipped the scales at nearly 14 tons, with the bulk of that weight consisting of toxic unsymmetrical dimethylhydrazine (UDMH) and nitrogen tetroxide fuel.

This unused rocket propellant remained onboard the spacecraft due to a malfunction that prevented Phobos-Grunt from firing its engine and beginning the journey to Mars. The failure left the probe marooned in Earth orbit instead.

Russian experts that assessed the re-entry survivability of Phobos-Grunt said before the craft’s destructive fall that about 20 to 30 fragments would reach Earth’s surface. It was estimated that less than 200 kilograms — some 400 pounds of hardware — would survive the plunge.

Phobos-Grunt launched into space on Nov. 8 (Nov. 9 in Moscow) on a mission aimed at landing on Phobos, one of two moons circling the Red Planet. Grunt means "soil" in Russian, and the probe was built to collect samples from Phobos and return them to Earth by 2014.

Mars probe's likely crash zone
In addition to the Phobos-Grunt re-entry data provided by the U.S. Strategic Command, other information on the spacecraft's fall to Earth was gleaned from European sources, including France and Germany. All of these readings were used to refine the re-entry estimates, ESA officials said.

"Within the expected uncertainties, the prediction has been largely confirmed by observations," they added.

As the errant Phobos-Grunt circled Earth prior to its demise, ESA officials sent regular updates to European civil protection authorities, the space agency said.

The U.S. Strategic Command operates a network of radar and other sensors — including space-based assets — that collectively track objects in orbit as well as scan for objects that plunge into Earth's atmosphere.

The final report regarding the Phobos-Grunt re-entry was posted Tuesday on the U.S. government's website that provides access to U.S. Air Force Space Surveillance data.

That website shows that the failed Russian probe (classified as Object 37872) made 1,097 orbits of Earth prior to its re-entry at 17:46:00 GMT, plus or minus one minute. The posting shows a predicted decay location of 46 degrees south, 273 degrees east.

[Amateur observers questioned why the re-entry information was missing from the Space-Track site for so long. They noted that the information gap was at odds with normal procedure. Klinkrad told that it was up to the U.S. Strategic Command to discuss that aspect of the Phobos-Grunt postmortem, but he emphasized that the re-entry data was always available to authorities. "It was not available to the outside world," he acknowledged.]

A global campaign
An international group known as the Inter-Agency Space Debris Coordination Committee, or IADC, took an active role in predicting the fall of Phobos-Grunt. This is a technical forum for the worldwide coordination of activities related to human-made and natural debris in space.

IADC is an interagency group with member agencies that include ESA, NASA, European national agencies and the Russian, Chinese, Canadian, Japanese, Ukrainian and Indian space agencies.

Since 1998, a number of targets have been used for IADC re-entry campaigns. The Phobos-Grunt re-entry was the third major spacecraft to fall from space in recent months. It followed the crash of a dead German X-ray space observatory in October and the re-entry of NASA's defunct Upper Atmospheric Research Satellite in September.

Data-sharing between countries has helped to sharpen skills to more accurately calculate the re-entries of spacecraft, rocket stages and even discarded hardware from the International Space Station.

Leonard David has been reporting on the space industry for more than five decades. He is a winner of last year's National Space Club Press Award and a past editor-in-chief of the National Space Society's Ad Astra and Space World magazines. He has written for since 1999.

This report was supplemented by's Alan Boyle.