IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.

Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin, in Israel, stresses need for 'independent judiciary' as legal reform protests disrupt his trip

Critics say the proposed legal reforms would upset Israel's delicate system of checks and balances and slide it toward authoritarianism.
Get more newsLiveon

TEL AVIV — Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin stressed the importance of an “independent judiciary” on a visit to Israel on Thursday, as thousands took to the streets across the country to protest against government proposals to overhaul the legal system.

Austin, whose schedule was rearranged to keep his engagements close to Israel’s main international airport, told a news conference that both countries “shared values of democracy and freedom and the rule of law.” 

“As President Biden has said, the genius of democracy, of American democracy and Israeli democracy is that they are both built on strong institutions, on checks and balances, and on an independent judiciary,” he said after meeting with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Defense Minister Yoav Galant.   

 Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin shakes hands with his Israeli counterpart Yoav Gallant in Tel Aviv on March 9, 2023.
Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin meets Thursday with his Israeli counterpart, Yoav Gallant, in Tel Aviv. Gil Cohen-Magen / AFP - Getty Images

His comments came after Netanyahu was airlifted by helicopter to the Ben Gurion Airport near Tel Aviv, according to The Associated Press, which reported that it was the only way he was able to elude the flag-waving Israelis who had blocked nearby roads. 

Launched as the “day of resistance to dictatorship,” the demonstrators made blocking Netanyahu’s route to the airport a centerpiece of their protests and the optics of the Israeli leader having to make alternate travel plans were a win for the movement.

Protesters blocked main intersections and scuffled with police in other cities and a small flotilla of paddleboards and kayaks tried to close off a main maritime shipping lane off the northern city of Haifa, the AP reported. It said that some protesters barricaded the Jerusalem offices of a conservative think tank helping to spearhead the judicial changes.

The legal overhauls were proposed in January, weeks after Netanyahu’s ultranationalist coalition, the most far-right government in Israeli history, was sworn in. The plan has increasingly divided the Israeli community and given momentum to weekly protests every Saturday. 

A demonstrator waves the Israeli flag Thursday in front of paramilitary border police in Tel Aviv during a protest against plans to overhaul the judicial system.
A demonstrator waves the Israeli flag Thursday in front of paramilitary border police in Tel Aviv during a protest against plans to overhaul the judicial system.Ariel Schalit / AP

The debate stems from fears that the changes would weaken the Supreme Court, limit judges’ powers and threaten democratic institutions. 

Netanyahu — who is on trial on graft charges — and his allies say the reforms will rein in an unelected judiciary and restore balance between the branches of government.

Critics say the overhaul will upset the country’s delicate system of checks and balances and slide Israel toward authoritarianism. They also say that Netanyahu is driven by personal grievances and that he could find an escape route from the corruption charges through the overhaul. Netanyahu denies wrongdoing, and says the legal changes have nothing to do with his trial.

Israelis protest plans to overhaul the judicial system in Tel Aviv on Thursday. Ohad Zwigenberg / AP

In Tel Aviv, some protesters said they hoped Austin and the U.S. would encourage the Israeli government to abandon the plans. 

“I would like to thank President Biden for expressing his concern for what is happening here,” said Sergei Leflanski, a team leader at a tech company. The 40-year-old added that the protesters will not let Netanyahu "ruin our country, we will not let him ruin our democracy, he will also have to answer this in court.”  

Liot Boxerman, 33, also called on Austin to tell Netanyahu that the legal overhaul was “not right.” 

“Democracy is in danger in Israel, and we have to fight for our rights,” she said.” They’re trying to take our rights away from us and we have to do something before it’s too late.”

She added that she was “very worried,” and “afraid that Israel won’t be the same anymore, that human rights won’t be valid anymore, women’s rights, gay rights.”  

Calling the changes a “threat to democracy,” architect Ilan Aviram, 30, said he was “really worried” that his two children “will grow in a place that is not a democracy but a dictatorship.” 

However, Netanyahu, who was flying to Italy for a meeting with Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni on Friday, played down the protests and vowed to push ahead with his program.   

In an interview with the Italian daily La Repubblica ahead of the trip, he said: “The protests show how solid our democracy is. A reform is necessary. The judiciary must be independent, not omnipotent.”

Raf Sanchez reported from Tel Aviv and Henry Austin reported from London.