IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser.
Last updated

Feb. 10 updates for impeachment trial Day 2: House Democrats present evidence in Senate

House impeachment managers showed new security footage of the violence at the Capitol riot during second day of trial.
Image: Illustration shows former President Donald Trump collaged with paper cut outs of Senators Chuck Schumer and Mitch McConnell with red strips reading \"high crimes\" and other phrases.
Chelsea Stahl / NBC News

House Democrats showed "chilling" new video and security footage Wednesday during the second day of former President Donald Trump's impeachment trial.

Audio of police dispatchers and video of the violence from Jan. 6, some of which had not previously been released publicly, detailed a nearly minute-by-minute account of what happened once the Capitol was breached by a mob. In the new security video, congressional staffers can be seen running for their lives and barricading themselves inside offices to escape the rioting mob.

Before that, House managers used particularly incendiary tweets from Trump, going as far back as July, to make their case of how he incited the riot at the Capitol.

The Senate voted to proceed with the trial on Tuesday after hearing about four hours of debate on the constitutionality of impeaching a former federal official. Trump was impeached for the second time last month for his role in the riot at the Capitol.

This live coverage had ended. Get the latest live updates here or go to for more coverage.

Read the latest updates below:

'Harsh reminder': Key takeaways from Day Two of Trump's second impeachment trial

Democrats played harrowing new video Wednesday of the riot that showed how close rioters intent on harming lawmakers came to finding them on Jan. 6, stoking raw emotions on the second day of former President Donald Trump's impeachment trial.

As the House impeachment managers recounted their experiences on Jan. 6 in emotional terms, they sought to make senators relive their own near-misses with the mob that invaded the U.S. Capitol.

It is unclear whether they swayed Republicans, and it remains unlikely that a two-thirds majority will vote to convict. But Democrats, who have charged Trump with being "singularly responsible" for inciting the assault, were determined to remind members of his party that their own safety and lives were in danger after he spoke to a crowd of supporters who soon turned violent and stormed the Capitol.

Click here for the key takeaways from an emotional day.

McConnell is still undecided on how he'll vote: source

Leigh Ann Caldwell

After an emotional and gripping day by House Impeachment managers in the Trump impeachment trial, Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell is still undecided on how he will vote on conviction, a source familiar with McConnell’s thinking tells NBC News. 

On February 2, McConnell told reporters that he’s “going to listen to what the lawyers have to say and making the arguments and work our way through it.”  That position “still stands,” the source says. 

McConnell has not discussed the contents of the trial with his conference nor has provided guidance or direction on how to vote at any point this week or since the trial began, three sources said. Senate Republicans have gathered at least twice this week for lunch and McConnell and his leadership team have met at least once. 

One Republican aide said McConnell’s lack of guidance is “confusing” and “no one knows” where he stands. 

Prior to the start of the trial, McConnell indicated that impeachment is a vote of conscience and then voted on Tuesday with other Republicans calling the impeachment of a president no longer in office unconstitutional.  


GOP Sen. Portman 'impressed' with House managers but doesn't see clear link to Trump

Dartunorro Clark

Sen. Rob Portman, R-Ohio, told reporters that he was "impressed" with House managers' presentation of their case Wednesday but that he doesn't see a clear link to former President Donald Trump. 

He said the harrowing videos revealed how unprotected the Capitol was and showed that staffers were in more danger than many lawmakers were. 

"I mean, we frankly were pretty well protected. And based on the footage, maybe not as protected as we thought we were," he said. 

Portman, who is retiring at the end of his term, previously voted against holding the trial, but he said he is keeping an open mind as a juror and listening to the evidence. 

"I've certainly been expressing myself plainly, you know. I said what he did that day was inexcusable. I said he's firmly responsible, and, you know, I've been clear," he said. "I'm impressed with the presenters. Yeah, that link, we'll see, because I think that's what they're going to try to do next."  

Highlights from Day Two arguments

Tuberville disputes Trump call during House managers' presentation

Dartunorro Clark

Sen. Tommy Tuberville, R-Ala., disputed a presentation Wednesday by House managers of calls and voicemails Donald Trump made to Republican lawmakers to delay the certification of the election as the riot unfolded in the Capitol. 

"Well, it was kind of unusual," Tuberville told reporters. "I wish that it'd been correct." 

The managers detailed the phone call between Tuberville and Trump during the riot. Trump called Sen. Mike Lee, R-Utah, intending to call Tuberville — making a connection of the former president's motives that day. 

House managers also played voicemails that Trump attorney Rudy Giuliani intended to send to Tuberville on the night of Jan. 6 pressuring senators to delay the election certification. The managers argued that Trump's sole focus was to stop the transfer of power.

"Well, I don't know if you've ever talked to President Trump. You don't get many words in, but he didn't get a chance to say a whole lot, because I said, 'Mr. President, they just took the vice president out, I've got to go,'" Tuberville said. 

Watching the clock

House managers wrapped up their first day of arguments at 7:40 p.m. ET after using 5 hours and 41 minutes of their allotted time on Wednesday.

They will have up to eight hours on Thursday when the trial resumes at noon to finish their arguments.


Romney personally thanks Officer Goodman for 'getting me back into the path of safety'

Dartunorro Clark

Sen. Mitt Romney, R-Utah, on Wednesday personally thanked the Capitol Police officer who led the rioters away from the Senate chamber during the Jan. 6 riot.

House managers displayed a video during their presentation of Officer Eugene Goodman turning Romney around during the attack to prevent him from running headlong into the mob. Romney said that in the video he was walking to his hideaway in the Capitol, but because rioters were in already in the Rotunda, Goodman redirected him. 

Romney said that was the first he'd seen that video and he had no idea how close he'd come to the attackers.

Romney recounted his conversation with Goodman, saying, “I express my appreciation to him for coming to my aid and getting me back into the path of safety and expressed my appreciation for all that he did that day.”

“Officer Goodman came and saw me and said, 'Go back in, it's not safe here, go back in and you'll be safer in the chamber,' so I came back in and took my seat,” Romney said.


Brief chaos as Sen. Lee demands a retraction; ends with Senate adjourning for the day

The House managers made a small retraction amid a protest from Sen. Mike Lee, R-Utah, who said that Democrats had misrepresented a call Trump made to him seeking to speak with Sen. Tommy Tuberville, R-Ala., amid the Capitol riot.

Lee said he wanted a segment from Rep. Cicilline's presentation about that phone call to be struck from the record, which led to brief chaos in the Senate chamber as Democrats and Republicans tried to figure out how to proceed. The situation was resolved after Raskin, the lead House manager, offered to give a brief statement clarifying the earlier remarks.

"The impeachment manager correctly and accurately quoted a newspaper account," Raskin said of the comments and CNN article in question. "We're happy to withdraw it on the grounds that it is not true. We're going to withdraw it this evening."

He added the ordeal was "much ado about nothing because it doesn't matter to our case."

Lee apparently took issue with how Cicilline described his role in the Trump/Tuberville phone call amid the riot, though he did not explain what was factually inaccurate about the remarks.

As both CNN and The Deseret News reported, Trump accidentally called Lee as he sought to speak with Tuberville, with CNN reporting that Trump sought to speak with the freshman Alabama senator about issuing further objections to the Electoral College vote count. Lee's office had confirmed to CNN that the phone call happened.

With that, the Senate wrapped for Wednesday. The trial will Thursday at noon.

Castro details timeline of Trump's public messaging during riot

Castro highlights GOP allies begging Trump to intervene

Graham blames Capitol Police for not killing more rioters

Frank Thorp Vproducer and off-air reporter

Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., a close ally of former President Donald Trump, told reporters that he believes "there's more votes for acquittal after today than there was yesterday."

"Because hypocrisy is pretty large for these people, standing up to, you know, rioters when they came to my house, Susan Collins' house, I think this is a very hypocritical presentation by the House," he claimed.

He also blamed Capitol Police officers for not having killed more rioters.

"I got mad. I mean, these police officers had every right to use deadly force. They should have used it," he said. "The people in charge of securing the Capitol let the country down."

House managers focus on Trump's failure to act once riot was underway

Returning from break, the House managers focused their argument on Trump's failure to act while the riot was ongoing.

Rep. Cicilline began by detailing the president's actions as the riot was underway, citing his tweets promoting his rally speech and attacking Pence as the Capitol was under attack as well as reports that said the president was watching the proceedings on TV.

Cicilline then asked the senators a rhetorical question: What was Trump doing to help them as Democrats and Republicans reached out to him and the White House seeking assistance?

"Nothing," Cicilline said. "Not a thing."

Cicilline mentioned the president's attempt to reach Sen. Tommy Tuberville, R-Ala., to get him to issue additional objections to the electoral college vote count as the riot was underway. He then contrasted that with footage of what was going on in and around the Capitol at that time.

House Republicans who voted to impeach Trump mentioned his hours-long delay in seeking to stop the riot as influential in their vote.

Inside the chamber, senators react to new evidence of how much danger they faced on Jan. 6

Senators were rattled Wednesday as Democratic impeachment managers gave them new details of how close the violent mob of Trump's supporters came to finding them on Jan. 6.

As Rep. Swalwell played not-seen-before footage of how close the rioters came to the Senate chamber, Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., sat expressionless but attentive, hands folded on his lap. Majority Leader Schumer had a hand on his forehead.

The chamber was in absolute silence as Swalwell showed the moment of Ashli Babbitt's death. There was longer silence of about 10 seconds when he showed new security footage of how close the rioters came to the Senate chamber — and asked them to imagine if they had breached the chamber just minutes earlier.

Some of the six Republicans who voted in favor of the constitutionality of the Senate trial were sitting next to each other — Bill Cassidy of Louisiana and Ben Sasse of Nebraska, and Susan Collins of Maine and Lisa Murkowski of Alaska.

As Swalwell showed evidence that Schumer had a "near-miss with the mob," the New York Democrat nodded in agreement.

Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, watched, attentive but nonreactive, as he watched the video captured by a reporter for the New Yorker of a rioter invoking Cruz's name to justify ransacking the Senate.

Murkowski: 'Don't see how Donald Trump could be re-elected to the presidency again'

Dartunorro Clark

Sen. Lisa Murkowski said that the evidence presented by House managers was disturbing and they "made a very strong case."

"The evidence that has been presented thus far is very damming," she told reporters. "I don't see how Donald Trump could be re-elected to the presidency again."

The Alaska Republican, however, said she is keeping an open mind as Trump's defense prepares to respond. 

She said what the House managers have presented made her "sad," as she had to relive the violent riot "with a more comprehensive timeline" of Trump's rhetoric fueling the anger of his supporters. 

Schumer: 'I don't think many of us feel like eating dinner' after viewing new video

Rebecca Shabadis in Washington, D.C.

In a brief statement during the dinner recess, Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., suggested that senators may have lost their appetites after viewing the video from Jan. 6. 

"I don't think many of us feel like eating dinner," Schumer told reporters. 

He said that he hopes his GOP colleagues keep open minds and that the House managers presented an "overwhelmingly compelling case" against Trump on Wednesday. 

Sen. King relays one unnamed GOP senator's emotional reaction to videos

Sen. Thune says House managers' arguments against Trump are 'very, very compelling'

Rebecca Shabadis in Washington, D.C.

Leigh Ann Caldwell

Rebecca Shabad and Leigh Ann Caldwell

Senate Minority Whip John Thune, R-S.D., said after viewing the new video from Jan. 6 that the case presented by the House impeachment managers is "very compelling" and suggested that he's not ruling out voting to convict former President Donald Trump.

The managers had a "strong, strong presentation, put together in a way that I think makes it very compelling," Thune told reporters. 

Asked whether the presentations had any impact on what he thinks about the trial so far, Thune said, "I said all along I was going to listen to the arguments and look at the evidence, and I'm doing that."

Thune said the managers were "very, very effective," and when he was asked whether he sees the connection between Trump's actions and the violence of Jan. 6, he said, "They've done a good job connecting the dots."

Romney reacts to new footage showing him hurrying away from rioters

Romney told reporters during the intermission that he did not know how close he was to the mob on Jan 6. as he walked down a hallway before a Capitol Hill police officer waved him in the other direction.

He added that he did not know at the time the officer who waved him down a different hallway was Eugene Goodman, who has been hailed as a hero for his actions during the riot.

Romney said he looks "forward to thanking him when I next see him," adding that he was "very fortunate indeed that Officer Goodman was there to get me in the right direction."

Earlier Wednesday, House managers showed security camera footage of Goodman rushing down a hallway and waving Romney in the other direction. Romney turned around and hurried away.

Sen. Rick Scott after viewing brutal new videos: 'This is a complete waste of time'

Rebecca Shabadis in Washington, D.C.

Sen. Rick Scott, R-Fla., told reporters after viewing the explicit videos of the attack on the Capitol the Senate trial is a "complete waste of time."

"I'm disgusted that, you know, people think that they can do things like that and get away with it. I hope everybody that came into the Capitol and did the wrong thing gets prosecuted to the full extent of law," Scott said. 

Asked if he thinks Trump bears any responsibility for the attack, Scott said, "Look, I've been clear that that I wish the president had said something faster when they broke into it, but, you know, I've watched what he said. He's never said when somebody should break in — [he] actually said that people should do this peacefully."

"This is a complete waste of time," he continued. "It's not doing anything to help American families, it's not helping people get jobs, it's not helping get the vaccine out ... it's vindictive."

Trial breaks for 45 minutes

Randi Richardson

The impeachment trial has recessed until 6:15 p.m. ET with about three hours remaining on Wednesday's proceedings.

New footage shows Schumer, Romney near misses with mob

During a segment led by Swalwell, the House managers played film of senators experiencing near misses with the mob.

The closest call appeared to be Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., who was shown on Capitol camera footage going down a hallway with his security detail only to quickly turn around and begin running in the opposite direction. 

Just prior to this, Swalwell played footage showing a number of senators leaving the Senate chamber and, later, running through a hallway to safety.

The footage of Schumer echoed an earlier security camera clip shown of Capitol Hill police officer Eugene Goodman rushing down a hallway and signaling to Sen. Mitt Romney, R-Utah, that he needed to turn around and go down a different path. Romney quickly turned around and began to hurry away.

Swalwell showed the new footage of the escape, details of which members of Congress have intentionally withheld for safety reasons. 

The footage created the juxtaposition of the senators, serving as jurors in the trial, having to watch their own escapes from rioters, in addition to having their desks ransacked.

House managers have been careful not to reveal locations of where lawmakers hid, Swalwell says

Rebecca Shabadis in Washington, D.C.

Swalwell says that throughout the House managers' presentation Wednesday, they've been careful not to reveal where lawmakers hid on the day of the attack on the Capitol. 

He said he has been careful not to share the paths that members of Congress took as they exited the House chamber on Jan. 6 after the Capitol was breached. 

"But that very issue was under discussion by the insurrectionists themselves," said Swalwell, who said that one affidavit by the FBI stated that the leader of the Oath Keepers militia group received messages while he was inside the Capitol and was being given directions to where representatives were "thought to be sheltering." 

Swalwell said that the leader was given directions to "turn on the gas" and "seal them in."

House managers show deadliest moment inside Capitol

Dartunorro Clark

Democratic Rep. Eric Swalwell detailed some of the deadliest moments of the Jan. 6 Capitol riot during his presentation. 

It included the video in which a Capitol Police officer shot and killed Ashli Babbitt, a 35-year-old Air Force veteran and ardent supporter of former President Donald Trump, as she tried to break through a barricaded door where lawmakers were located. 

Videos showed rioters who made it into the building breaking glass on doors near the House chamber, which were blocked haphazardly from the inside with chairs in an attempt to prevent the mob from entering. As Babbitt tried to climb through the shattered glass, she was fatally shot by a Capitol Police officer who fired at her once.

Investigators have determined the Capitol Police officer who shot Babbitt should not be charged with any crimes, a law enforcement source familiar with the investigation previously told NBC News.

Swalwell also showed videos of the police response to the riot as well as moments where lawmakers were telling each other to take off their congressional pins as to not be identified by rioters. 

Plaskett shows video footage of rioters searching for Pelosi, staffers running to safety

Rebecca Shabadis in Washington, D.C.

Plaskett sought to show how Pelosi was in grave danger on Jan. 6, showing video footage of rioters inside the Capitol yelling and searching for her. 

Pelosi had been evacuated from the House chamber when the building was breached and brought to an undisclosed secure location outside of the Capitol complex. 

Plaskett showed security footage from a hallway that showed Pelosi staffers running into a room where they barricaded the doors with furniture. She played audio of the staffers hiding in the room whispering that they were looking for the speaker. 

She also said that the man who ransacking Pelosi's office, Richard Barnett, who was seen sitting with his feet up on the speaker's desk that day in a photo, had a powerful stun gun on him. He pleaded not guilty to charges against him last week.

Romney's son thanks Goodman for helping his father in jarring video

House managers use Trump's attacks on Pence to make their case

Randi Richardson

House managers are using former President Trump's attacks on his vice president as evidence of inciting the Jan. 6 Capitol riot.

House manager Stacey Plaskett, Dl-VI., showed new footage of former Vice President Pence evacuating the Capitol. The video shows Pence and his family being quickly escorted down a staircase to safety.

Plaskett also showed footage of rioters chanting "hang Mike Pence" while gathered around gallows erected outside.

Earlier in the trial, fellow House manager Ted Lieu, D-CA., emphasized how Trump verbally punching Pence prompted rioters to attack the Capitol in search of him and any one else opposing Trump or his efforts to overturn the election results. 

New footage shows Officer Goodman rushing to direct Romney as mob breached Capitol

The House managers showed new security camera footage featuring Eugene Goodman, the Capitol Hill police officer widely praised for helping divert a mob from breaching the Senate chamber early in the riot, rushing to help guide Sen. Mitt Romney, R-Utah, to safety as rioters breached the Capitol.

Plaskett said in introducing the footage that there was "more to his heroic story."

"In this security footage, you can see Officer Goodman running to respond to the initial breach," she said.

The footage shows Goodman rushing down a hallway toward Romney, waving him to turn around and take a different path. Romney then turn and hurried down the hallway Goodman had directed him toward. 

Romney didn't move while video played of him being guided away from mob

Sen. Mitt Romney didn’t move when they showed the video of Officer Eugene Goodman directing him away from rioters. Romney has a mask on so it's hard to see his reaction, beyond just blinking rapidly. But he was watching intently.

The volume inside the chamber is downright deafening and any senator not watching the video presentations is without question hearing it, very loudly.

Plaskett plays new audio, video of rioters violently entering the Capitol

Rebecca Shabadis in Washington, D.C.

Plaskett began laying out a nearly minute-by-minute account of what happened once the Capitol was breached by playing audio of police dispatchers and video of the violence from Jan. 6, some of which had not previously been released publicly.

"Multiple Capitol injuries. Multiple Injuries," an officer says in one audio clip. 

The dispatcher says, "You've got a group of about 50 charging up the hill on the west front just north of the stairs. They are approaching the wall." 

An officer is heard pleading for reinforcements, saying that rioters were pulling down security gates and throwing metal poles at officers. An officer also said the people began to throw explosives. 

In another piece of audio, a dispatcher responds to an officer and declares the Capitol attack a riot just before 2 p.m. ET. She also played video of rioters outside the Capitol attacking police and breaking down windows.


Trial outcome does not change Trump's ban from Twitter

Randi Richardson

Twitter told CNBC the morning of the second day of the impeachment trial that it would continue its ban against former President Trump regardless of whether he runs for office in 2024.

House managers have been using particularly incendiary tweets from Trump as far back as July to make their case of how he incited the Jan. 6 riot at the Capitol.

If convicted at the trial, Trump would become ineligible to run for public office again. Twitter said the outcome of the impeachment trial does not change its decision to permanently remove Trump from the platform.

Read the full story here. 

Trial resumes after brief recess

Rebecca Shabadis in Washington, D.C.

The trial has resumed after a brief recess with Del. Stacey Plaskett of the U.S. Virgin Islands speaking.

Trial breaks for 15 minutes

Randi Richardson

The impeachment trial has recessed for 15 minutes following Dean's presentation.

NBC's Garrett Haake: House managers show how supporters took Trump literally

'I will never forget that sound': Rep. Dean gets emotional recounting Jan. 6 attack

Rebecca Shabadis in Washington, D.C.

Rep. Madeleine Dean, D-Pa., became emotional as she recounted how Jan. 6 unfolded while she was inside the Capitol, saying the events that day are "forever etched in our memories." 

Dean said she went to work that day "with a sense of excitement" because it was the beginning of her second term in the House and was the first time she would participate in the counting of electoral votes in Congress. 

She said that she stood in the House gallery with her colleagues as they observed Republicans challenging the Arizona results for Biden, and moments later they heard on police radios that the building had been breached. 

"Someone shouted up to us, 'Duck!'" she recounted, saying they all then got down on the floor. "Shortly after, there was a terrifying banging on the chamber doors." 

"I will never forget that sound," she said, choking up, saying that she made panicked calls to her husband and son. 

Dean said the chaos that day was inspired by Trump, adding, "You saw a man willing to attack anyone and everyone who got in his way, and you saw a man who thought he could play by different rules."

Read the NBC report Plaskett cited about the anticipation of violence ahead of riot

Explaining the many warnings from law enforcement agencies and others ahead of the Capitol riot, Del. Stacey Plaskett cited an NBC News report that said online forums popular with conservatives and far-right activists were filled with threats and expectations of violence before the rally that preceded the deadly events.

Read the report.

Plaskett refers to Trump's 'stand back and stand by' debate comment, caravan harassing Biden campaign

Rebecca Shabadis in Washington, D.C.

Del. Stacey Plaskett argued that Trump knew his supporters would be violent because of warnings from law enforcement and specifically encouraged them to engage in such acts. 

Plaskett, of the U.S. Virgin Islands, said that just as Trump spent months spreading his "big lie," he also spent months "cultivating groups of people" who followed his commands and engaged in violence. 

"He fanned the flame of violence," Plaskett said. "The violence was what he deliberately encouraged." 

The lawmaker played a clip from the presidential debate in September 2020 when Trump addressed far-right extremists such as the Proud Boys "to stand back and stand by." She said that the group thereafter adopted that phrase as their slogan. 

She also showed video footage of a caravan of Trump supporters surrounding a Biden campaign bus in October in Texas as it traveled from San Antonio to Austin, which resulted in two cars colliding. The Biden campaign said the pro-Trump trucks tried to run the bus off the road. 

The FBI announced afterward that it would investigate the incident. 

Lieu: Trump turned on fellow Republicans ahead of Capitol attack

Randi Richardson

House manager Ted Lieu, D-CA., focused his presentation on showing how former President Trump sought to pressure fellow Republicans, including former Vice President Mike Pence and members of his Cabinet, to aid his efforts to overturn the election result.

Trump singled out Republican lawmakers, some of whom were in the room, in regular tweets, asking them to stand with him and against the "stolen" election. As the inauguration approached, Trump began to also focus his ire on Pence.

Lieu said Trump lashing out at his party members further drove his base to support him by attacking the Capitol, with some directly targeting the vice president.

Trump's Georgia lies started online

The House impeachment managers played clips of Trump’s call with Georgia officials, where he pushed officials and alleged widespread voter fraud.

Some of the claims repeated by the president during that call trace back to QAnon followers and extremist forums like 4chan, where the baseless conspiracy theories repeated by Trump had been floating around for months.

Read the full story here.

Dean: Trump 'relentless' about efforts to overturn election

Randi Richardson

Impeachment manager Madeleine Dean, D-Pa., detailed how Trump was "relentless" in contacting local and state officials to overturn election results, including in Georgia, Michigan and Pennsylvania — all swing states that he lost.

Dean played an audio clip of Gabriel Sterling, an election official in Georgia, saying, "Someone's going to get shot, someone's going to get killed," weeks before the Jan. 6 violence at the Capitol — showing the threats were clear well before the riot.

Trial resumes

Randi Richardson

The impeachment trial has resumed with House manager Madeleine Dean, D-Pa., opening with remarks about how former President Trump filed numerous lawsuits opposing the election results.

Dean said Trump filed and lost over 60 lawsuits, showing that he refused to accept the election results and continued to undermine the legitimacy of the election.

Hawley, other GOP senators seem distracted during key arguments


Kasie Hunt

Leigh Ann Caldwell

Kasie Hunt, Julie Tsirkin and Leigh Ann Caldwell

WASHINGTON — As House managers delivered their arguments for why Trump should be covicted, some Senate Republicans seemed distracted. 

Josh Hawley, R-Mo., sitting directly across from the TV press gallery with his feet up on the chair, continued to read papers in unmarked manila folders. He later told pool reporters that he was looking at "trial briefs with me and I've also got my notes that I'm taking."

"I haven't seen anything that's new or different," he told reporters, adding, "I think they've thought through the presentation very carefully and have clearly, you know, worked it into a very a manner that's easy to follow and I think they've clearly worked on it.” But, he said, "There's nothing new here, for me. At the end of the day, I think that we don't have jurisdiction as a court in order to pursue this, so nothing that I've seen changes my view on that and if you don't have jurisdiction, that's just the end of the call."

Mike Braun, R-Ind., at times appeared to be struggling to stay awake. Marsha Blackburn, R-Tenn., wasn’t paying much attention either as Rep. Neguse was going through his presentation, even as the two senators sitting next to her — Steve Daines of Montana and James Lankford of Oklahoma — were turned, looking past her at the TV screens.

Rand Paul, R-Ky., was doodling again what appeared to be a drawing of the Capitol building (and a rather sophisticated one at that.) Rick Scott, R-Fla., was studying what appeared to be a map of Southeast Asia.

There was one moment when everyone in the chamber seemed to turn to pay attention: When Neguse quoted rioters saying they were inspired by Trump, showing slides of tweets and news stories and playing clips of video.

Nearly every lawmaker had a mask on except for Cynthia Lummis, R-Wyo., whose mask was completely off her face at one point.

Trial breaks for 15 minutes

Randi Richardson

The impeachment trial has recessed for 15 minutes after hearing the beginning of the House managers' arguments.

Wednesday's proceedings are expected to last around eight hours with two more breaks.

About that Detroit vote: Trump gained ground in the city while lying about the totals

Rep. Eric Swalwell, D-Calif., showed video of Trump saying there were more votes in Detroit than people, and then explained that there are far more registered voters in the city — and even more residents — than people who voted.

What makes Trump’s lie particularly curious is something that Swalwell didn’t note: Trump actually did better there than he did in 2016:

  • Hillary Clinton won Detroit, 234,871 votes to Trump’s 7,682.
  • Joe Biden won with fewer votes, while Trump got more, in 2020: 233,908 to 12,654.

Swalwell illustrates Trump's desperation after losing the election

Rebecca Shabadis in Washington, D.C.

Rep. Eric Swalwell, D-Calif., another impeachment manager, illustrated how desperate Trump was after he lost the presidential election. 

"Day after day he told his supporters false, outlandish lies that the victory, that the election outcome was taken and it was rigged. And he had absolutely no support for his claims, but that wasn't the point. He wanted to make his base angrier and angrier. And to make them angry he was willing to say anything," Swalwell said. 

Swalwell then read aloud a number of false tweets Trump posted in the wake of Biden's victory in which Trump claimed, without evidence, that the election was rigged, that dead people voted, and that he found "many illegal votes." 

"This just wasn't true. He never found illegal votes. He didn't even try to pretend that he had evidence for that," Swalwell said.

Experts: Trump’s 'big lie' didn’t start with him

The impeachment managers are focused on Trump’s actions during this trial, but it’s worth noting that the "big lie” of a stolen election didn’t happen in a vacuum: many other Republicans — including some in the Senate — have been claiming that voter fraud was a big problem for decades.

“The base was completely prepared to believe the kind of outlandish things that Trump said," said Rick Hasen, a professor and election law expert at the University of California, Irvine told NBC News recently.

"No matter how powerful his bully pulpit, he wouldn't have a fertile — he wouldn't have a willing audience if this had not been repeated so many times over the years in a more polite voice," added Michael Waldman, president of the Brennan Center for Justice at New York University School of Law.

Read the full story here.

Castro says Trump's efforts to delegitimize election began long before Jan. 6

Randi Richardson

House manager Joaquin Castro, D-Texas, pulled quotes from as far back as July 2020 to demonstrate how former President Trump's efforts to delegitimize the election began long before Jan. 6

Castro played a video reel showing Trump repeatedly refusing to commit to a peaceful transfer of power.

In one clip, Trump says, "There won't be a transition of power. There'll be a continuation." 

Castro also played clips of supporters saying they wouldn't accept a "rigged" election to show the effect of his messaging.

The House managers are using these anecdotes to argue that Trump's crimes are not summed up with just the Capitol attack, but rather it marked the end of a progression spiraling downward.

Neguse says Trump's supporters were 'primed' for Capitol attack for months

Rebecca Shabadis in Washington, D.C.

Neguse argued that Trump supporters were "primed" for the Jan. 6 attack over many months and that law enforcement agencies knew in the days before that thousands of people planned to target the Capitol, that they'd be armed and violent. 

The Democratic manager then showed a clip of Trump at his "Stop the Steal" rally that day near the White House ellipse.

"You have to get your people to fight because you'll never take back a country with weakness, you have to show strength and you have to be strong. And we fight, we fight like hell. And if you don't fight like hell, you're not going to have a country anymore," Trump told his supporters. 

Neguse said Trump "had the power to stop" the violence but didn't. The lawmaker also cited a comment from a Proud Boy member charged in the riot who said they would have killed then-Vice President Mike Pence if they had the opportunity. Neguse then read a quote in a criminal complaint of a rioter saying, "We were looking for Nancy Pelosi, to shoot her in the frickin' brain, but we didn't find her."

Rep. Neguse: Election officials warned us

Rep. Joe Neguse, D-Colo., pointed to the harassment of election officials as an early warning sign last year, a warning he says the president pointedly ignored.

“Armed supporters surrounded election officials’ homes," Neguse said. "The secretary of state for Georgia got death threats. Officials warned the president that his rhetoric was dangerous and was going to result in deadly violence. When he saw the violence his conduct was creating, he didn’t stop it. He didn’t condemn it. He incited it further.” 

NBC News recently spoke with a dozen election officials who described months of abuse and threats and how they tried to raise the alarm ahead of the deadly attack at the Capitol.

Read the story here.

Neguse lays out in chronological order a roadmap of what led to Jan. 6 attack

Rebecca Shabadis in Washington, D.C.

Rep. Joe Neguse, D-Colo., in his opening arguments, provided a timeline of what led up to the Jan. 6 attack on the Capitol as well as a roadmap of Democrats' arguments.

Neguse said that as a son of immigrants, he believes in his heart that the U.S. is the greatest republic the world has ever known. 

"We know now that we can no longer take that for granted," he said. 

The mob on Jan. 6 was "summoned assembled and incited by the former president of the United States, Donald Trump. And he did that because he wanted to stop the transfer of power so that he could retain power, even though he had lost the election," Neguse said. 

He said that the events of that day were "predictable" and "foreseeable" as his supporters were "well-orchestrated." Neguse laid out in chronological order what led to the riot which began with Trump promoting what is now known as "the big lie," stating that he won the election, then encouraging his supporters to "stop the steal" of the election and then telling his supporters to "fight like hell."

The impeachment manager told senators that if they want to prevent such an event from happening again, then Trump must be convicted.

Democratic impeachment manager quotes Scalia in case against Trump

Rep. Jamie Raskin, D-Md., the lead impeachment manager, tugged at conservative heartstrings Wednesday when he quoted former Justice Antonin Scalia as part of his case for convicting former President Trump.

"As Justice Scalia once said, memorably, you can't ride with the cops and root for the robbers," Raskin said, referring to a 1987 opinion Scalia wrote in the significant First Amendment case Rankin v. McPherson.

Raskin was arguing that incitement to violence is not protected speech under the First Amendment.

ANALYSIS: Forget ideology, it’s about a president inciting an insurrection

Lead House impeachment manager,Jamie Raskin, D-Md., made a subtle point aimed at getting Republican senators to think about the Jan. 6 riot outside the specific context of a pro-Trump action.

The ideology of the Trump supporters is irrelevant to the question of whether the president’s conduct requires conviction by the Senate. A president cannot incite an insurrection and “expect to be on the payroll as commander in chief of the union.”

The ideology, he said, “makes no difference.”

Raskin says Democrats will prove Trump was 'no innocent bystander' on Jan. 6

Rebecca Shabadis in Washington, D.C.

Raskin began his opening arguments Wednesday by saying his team will prove that Trump was "no innocent bystander" in the events of Jan. 6.

"He saw it coming," said Raskin, who also said that the former president had been warned that his followers would cause violence.

"There was method in the madness that day," he said. 

Raskin said that the trial is about "holding accountable the person singularly responsible for inciting the attack," referring to Trump. 

The Maryland Democrat then highlighted key lines from Trump's "Stop the Steal" rally before the attack on the Capitol in which he told his supporters that they wouldn't have a country anymore and would never take the country back with weakness. 

"This is a day that will live in disgrace in American history," he added.

Second day of impeachment trial opens

Randi Richardson

The second day of the second impeachment trial of former President Donald Trump began at 12 p.m. ET on Wednesday with the House managers making their opening arguments. 

The day's proceedings, led by Rep. Jaime Raskin, D-Md., is expected to last around eight hours with three breaks. The managers are expected to show unreleased footage of the deadly Jan. 6 Capitol attack.

Defense team lawyer rejects reports that Trump unhappy with Tuesday performance

Rebecca Shabadis in Washington, D.C.

One of Trump's attorneys rejected reports that the former president expressed displeasure with their performance during the first day of the trial Tuesday.

"Far from it," Bruce Castor told reporters Wednesday. "Only one person’s opinion matters and that is what I am going by."

Another lawyer on the defense team, David Schoen, said that he had spoken to Trump but would not divulge what was said.

"Of course any conversation that I had, as I am sure you understand, are attorney-client privileges," he said.

Senate Judiciary Committee announces Merrick Garland confirmation dates

Dartunorro Clark

The Senate Judiciary Committee has set a confirmation hearing for Merrick Garland, President Joe Biden's nominee for attorney general.

The two-day hearing will begin on Feb. 22 and include Garland's testimony and a second day for outside witnesses to testify. Lawmakers have said that Trump's impeachment trial would not impede their legislative work or confirming Biden's nominees. 

A committee vote will take place the following Monday on whether to move the nomination to the full Senate. Many of Biden's nominees have faced little resistance to getting confirmed from Republicans in the Senate, which is narrowly controlled by Democrats. 

Garland, a federal appeals court judge whose nomination to the Supreme Court in 2016 was stalled by Republicans, has previously had top roles at the Justice Department. 

Georgia prosecutors open criminal inquiry into Trump's efforts to overturn election results

Georgia prosecutors have launched a criminal investigation into former President Donald Trump’s efforts to overturn the state's election results, NBC News confirmed Wednesday.

The investigation by Fulton County prosecutors will look into a damning phone call that Trump made to Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger while he was still president in which Trump begged him to overturn the results.

Fulton County prosecutor Fani Willis sent a letter Wednesday to state government officials, including Raffensperger, requesting that their offices preserve documents related to the call, according to a state official with knowledge of the letter.

NBC News verified the contents of the letter, which explicitly states the request is part of a criminal investigation into several charges ranging from false statements to “any involvement in violence or threats related to the election’s administration.”

Read more on the breaking story here.

Image: A banner reading, 'Convict or be complicit' is hung over a bridge in view of the U.S. Capitol

Image: A banner reading, "Convict or be complicit" is hung over a bridge in view of the U.S. Capitol
A banner reading, "Convict or be complicit" is hung over a bridge in view of the Capitol on the first day of the Senate impeachment trial against former President Donald Trump in Washington, on Feb. 9, 2021.Erin Scott / Reuters

Never-seen-before security video of Capitol riot to open Trump impeachment trial Day 2

Alex Moe

Adam Edelman and Alex Moe

Democratic House impeachment managers will unveil "never-seen-before" video of the deadly Capitol riot during their opening arguments Wednesday as part of the case they're building against former President Donald Trump, senior aides said.

The Capitol security footage "will provide new insight into both the extreme violence that everyone saw, the risk and the threat that it could have led to further violence and death to many but for the brave actions of the officers and shows really the extent of what Donald Trump unleashed on our Capitol," the aides to the impeachment managers told reporters.

"We have the goods," they said. "Yesterday was our dry constitutional argument day. Today, the actual trial begins. We have the goods, we will be presenting the goods. We will be tying the evidence all together in a compelling case that will make it clear for everyone — Democrats, Republicans, everyone — that Donald Trump committed the most heinous constitutional crime possible."

The video "shows a view of the Capitol that is quite extraordinary and a view of the attack that has never been public before," the aides added in previewing the team's approach for the second day of Trump's second impeachment trial.

Read more here.

FIRST READ: Trump's second impeachment trial is underway and the verdict is already in


Mark Murray

Carrie Dann

Melissa Holzberg

Chuck Todd, Mark Murray, Carrie Dann and Melissa Holzberg

After yesterday’s harrowing 13-minute video presentation, after hearing about the precedent and the Founders’ intentions, and after a widely panned defense presentation, only six Republican senators voted that Donald Trump’s impeachment trial is constitutional.

Those six GOP senators (out of 50) joined the 10 House Republicans (out of 211) who voted to impeach the former president in January, as well as the 11 House Republicans (out of 211) who voted to strip Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene’s, R-Ga., committee assignments last week.

The unmistakable conclusion: Trump and Trumpism have won the GOP’s civil war — even after Trump’s defeat in November, after the party lost control of the U.S. Senate, and after what happened on Jan. 6.

Get more First Read.

Georgia secretary of state's office opens inquiry into Trump phone call


Blayne Alexander

Charlie Gile

Blayne Alexander, Charlie Gile and Dareh Gregorian

Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger's office has opened an investigation into former President Trump's Jan. 2 phone call urging Raffensperger to overturn the state's election results.

"All I want to do is this: I just want to find 11,780 votes, which is one more than we have. Because we won the state," Trump told Raffensperger in the phone call, which is expected to play a prominent role in Trump's impeachment trial this week.

In a statement last month, Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis described the call as "disturbing" and left the door open for an investigation.

"Anyone who commits a felony violation of Georgia law in my jurisdiction will be held accountable. Once the investigation is complete, this matter, like all matters, will be handled by our office based on the facts and the law," Willis said then.

Read more about the call here.

Legal scholar chides Trump impeachment defense for misrepresenting his writings

A legal scholar who believes former officials can be the subject of impeachment and trial by the Senate said Tuesday that former President Trump's legal team has repeatedly mischaracterized his findings.

Brian Kalt, a professor at Michigan State University's College of Law, said the Trump legal brief submitted to the Senate on Monday "ranges from sloppy to disingenuous" in its citations to his 2001 law review article that concluded the Senate has the authority to impeach former officials.

Kalt's 124-page article spelled out the arguments on both sides of the question.

"There is plenty in there for them to use. The problem was that they did not cite accurately," he told NBC News as the Senate prepared to begin considering the issue.

Read more here.

Trump said to be extremely displeased with his legal team's first showing

Monica Alba, Hallie Jackson and Kristen Welker

Former President Donald Trump is extremely displeased about his legal team’s first showing at the Senate impeachment trial, according to three sources familiar with his thinking. He was especially disappointed with Bruce Castor’s meandering performance and wasn’t completely sold on David Schoen either, the sources said.

Trump, who watched and fumed from his Mar-a-Lago club, is expecting a more compelling appearance from the defense later in the week, one source said. 

In response to questions about Tuesday’s change in strategy, Castor told NBC News that his game-time decision to alter the plan was “not that complicated” and argued that he didn’t want to let Schoen follow the House impeachment managers’ case with a “dry” legal argument.

“I suggested at the break that I try to bring the room back from the ‘horrors’ the Ds tried to show that did not pertain to jurisdiction. It was a unanimous decision on our side for me to try to do so,” Castor added. He declined to comment directly on the widespread criticism of his remarks. 

Castor also said his goal was to “lower the temperature” and believed he was successful. “I was not trying to be scholarly, just informative. We will be scholarly later,” Castor said. 

Trump lawyer defends Castor, who was criticized for defense's opening remarks

Dartunorro Clark

Trump defense attorney David Schoen defended fellow team member Bruce Castor, who was criticized for his opening statement in the former president's defense during the first week of the impeachment trial, in a Fox News interview Tuesday night. 

Sean Hannity told Schoen that he found fellow lawyer Castor’s introductory performance “free-associating, extemporaneous, somewhat meandering,” and asked whether we can expect the Trump team’s response on Friday and Saturday to be “more focused and … more prepared.” 

Schoen said the team will be “very well prepared in the future.” 

"They seem to be very capable people," Schoen said of Castor's law firm. "Today, he hadn't planned on going. And so, I'm sure that they'll be very well prepared in the future, and do a great job in the case.”

Trump never conceded he lost, but his impeachment lawyer did

The Associated Press

One of the lawyers heading former President Donald Trump’s defense at his second impeachment trial did what Trump himself has not: conceded Joe Biden won the presidential election. 

In opening remarks Tuesday, lawyer Bruce Castor said: “The American people just spoke, and they just changed administrations.” He added that Americans are "smart enough to pick a new administration if they don’t like the old one, and they just did.”

The comments by Castor, a former county prosecutor in Pennsylvania, were a surprising contrast to Trump's defiance. The former president repeatedly disputed the results of the election, falsely claiming he won in a “landslide.” And he kept up the baseless claims through the end of his presidency, including during a speech at a rally that preceded the Jan. 6 riot at the Capitol, which set in motion his trial on a charge of incitement of insurrection.

Castor acknowledged more than once that Trump lost the election. Trump, for his part, never acknowledged his departure was the voters' will. While Vice President Mike Pence called his successor, Kamala Harris, to offer his congratulations, Trump made no similar call to Biden.

Who are Trump's impeachment lawyers?

Former President Donald Trump's impeachment legal team is comprised of a team of veteran lawyers, but none of them have ever been involved in a case quite like this.

While Trump's first impeachment trial featured prominent names such as former Whitewater prosecutor Ken Starr, former Florida Attorney General Pam Bondi and longtime Harvard Law professor Alan Dershowitz, Trump's current team has less name recognition, but decades of legal experience under their belts - and some familiarity with controversial clients.

Here's a look at Trump's legal team:

David Schoen is a civil and criminal defense lawyer who previously represented Trump adviser Roger Stone, whom Trump granted a full pardon during his final weeks in office. 

Bruce Castor is a former acting attorney general and state solicitor general in Pennsylvania, where he also served two terms as Montgomery County District Attorney. He had a string of successful prosecutions as D.A. but is best known for a case he declined to prosecute — a sexual assault case against comedian and actor Bill Cosby in 2005.

Michael Van der Veen is a Philadelphia-based personal injury and criminal defense lawyer. He founded the firm where Bruce Castor also works.

Julieanne Bateman is the youngest member of Team Trump, Bateman also works at van der Veen's firm. She is a former prosecutor at Pennsylvania's Franklin County District Attorney's office.

Trump Senate impeachment trial II: Everything you need to know

Donald Trump's second impeachment trial this week will look much different than the first.

Trump is the first president to be impeached twice by the House of Representatives, and he'll be the first former president to be put on trial in the Senate. Arguments begin in earnest on Wednesday, and the trial is expected to last at least a week. Here's what to expect.

Democrats say impeachment trial won't impede Covid relief work

Rebecca Shabadis in Washington, D.C.

Top Senate Democrats said Tuesday that they won't let the impeachment trial of former President Trump impede their legislative work and that they can tackle their agenda simultaneously.

Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., flanked by Democratic committee chairs, said at a news conference that Democrats had a message for those who said "the impeachment trial would throw a wrench into President Biden's early agenda."

"We are here today to say we are not letting that happen. We can do both at once," Schumer said.

Read more here.

Key takeaways from day one of Trump's second impeachment trial

The first day of Trump's second impeachment trial began with a graphic video of the Jan. 6 riot at the U.S. Capitol — and ended with a clue to the endgame.

After a first round of arguments by the House Democratic managers and Trump's defense team Tuesday, 56 senators voted to dismiss Trump's constitutional objections and continue with the trial — the latest sign that there won't be 67 votes to convict.

The trial represents a series of historic firsts: the first trial of a former president, the first time a president has faced two trials and the first time the chief justice of the United States isn't presiding when a president is on trial.

Here are four takeaways from the first day.

Just catching up? Here's what you missed from Tuesday's proceedings

The Senate voted Tuesday to proceed with the impeachment trial against former President Donald Trump, with six Republicans joining all Democrats.

The 56-44 vote rejected an argument from Trump's lawyers that it is unconstitutional to try a former president, a debate that took up much of the first day of arguments from the House impeachment managers and Trump's legal team.

Voting alongside all Senate Democrats were Sens. Pat Toomey, R-Pa., Lisa Murkowski, R-Alaska, Mitt Romney, R-Utah, Ben Sasse, R-Neb., Susan Collins, R-Maine, and Bill Cassidy, R-La.

Trump's second impeachment trial kicked off earlier Tuesday afternoon with a jarring 20-minute video montage of the devastating events of the Capitol riots, forcing the chamber of senators to relive some of the most intense moments from Jan. 6, some of which occurred at the very desks at which they were sitting.

Read more about Tuesday's debate here.